Dogs are loyal pets that add to our lives with love and laughter. As pet owners, if we care about our beloved dogs, we should provide them with toys made from safe materials.
Toys made of synthetic materials like plastic should be avoided. These eight natural toys are great and safe for dogs playtime.
Why Should We Choose Natural Dog Toys?
Natural dog toys have become popular among pet owners because of safety concerns, environmental awareness, and a desire to not use products derived from animals.
Dog Safety
Dog owners who are concerned about their pets’ health and safety should provide their dogs with only natural toys.
Natural rubber, organic cotton, or hemp are just a few examples of the non-toxic ingredients that go into making these toys. They safeguard dogs from potential choking hazards, gastrointestinal troubles, and metabolism and immune system abnormalities.
You can’t go wrong with natural rubber, bamboo, organic cotton, organic wool, or a hemp or jute based product.
Toys for dogs should be made only of safe materials, so learning what those are is crucial here.
Environmental Impact
Sustainable Material: Producers of natural dog toys use renewable resources, including cotton, rubber, and hemp, in their products. There will be less of an effect on the environment because these products usually contain no potentially harmful pesticides or fertilizers. In the dog toy industry, it is important to acknowledge and reward businesses that are making sustained strides.
Biodegradability: Toys made from plant materials or organic materials are better for the environment than their plastic counterparts since they endure longer, break down safely over time, and don’t add to landfill waste.
Ethical Manufacturing Practices
Animal Testing: Toys for dogs could have been tested on animals, ignoring the potential for pain and death. Researching the brand and manufacturing process is necessary for avoiding supporting such atrocities.
Material Sourcing: The exploitation of animals, such as through factory farming or widespread trapping, is a common source of the raw materials used to make dog toys.
Products derived from animals, such as rawhide (usually produced from cowhide), are widely used in dog toys. Dogs love rawhide chews because they last longer and have a more natural flavor than other kinds of treats.
But the chemicals used to process rawhide can be harmful to the environment, and the rawhide itself poses a choking and digestive health risk to pets. A dog chewing on it can cause it to enlarge and get lodged in its throat. Therefore, it is recommended that rawhide be used rarely.
Best Natural Dog Toys: Our Top Picks
1. Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks
- Editor rating: 9.5/10
Detailed Review
The Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks are one of the more unusual options here, but they have won me over. These chews are the most all-natural treat I’ve ever given my dog because they’re made with a single ingredient: 100% beef. Because they are grass-fed, non-GMO, and grain-free, I can feel good about giving them to my dog as a gift.
You won’t find better quality bully sticks than these. There are no leftovers or low-quality bits like you could get from other brands.
When it comes to bully sticks, size matters, and Natural Farm delivers. You got a lot of sticks for your money considering that a 1 pound bag has about 38 to 40 of them.
The sticks are not pencil thin; rather, they are quite wide and thick, with some even being classified as “jumbo.” This makes them more durable and gives dogs more time to enjoy chewing. The sticks vary in color from a pale tan to a deep brown, but all of them are of the same high quality.
Natural Farm is an honest brand that uses its own Brazilian production plant. The sticks are also not irradiated and are put through a heat treatment process. You can now be assured that the product is of the highest quality and safety standards.
Even though we can’t smell the scent that these sticks give off, they have a detectable smell to dogs, and our dogs really enjoy them.
Bear in mind, though, that you may be disappointed because, unlike chew toys, chew sticks can be swiftly worn down. There are also some inconsistencies in stick sizes, including thinner ones, and variations within the same package. I’ve also seen some staining on surfaces, including pillows, beds, and carpets. And these sticks can give off a foul scent if you are strongly sensitive to smell.
In general, I highly recommend these bully sticks for their single ingredient composition, grass-fed sourcing, and fully digestible nature to any dog owner looking to provide their dog with a safe and nutritious chewing experience.
| Pros | Cons |
| Long-lasting chewing experience | Can be consumed quickly, reducing lifespan |
| Natural and single ingredient (100% beef) | Inconsistent sizes, with some sticks being thinner |
| Promotes dental health and helps reduce plaque | Hardness concerns for certain dogs |
| Fully digestible and low in fat | Staining issues on surfaces like pillows beds, carpets |
| Available in various sizes and quantities | Potential digestive problems |
| Come in bulk, great value for the price |
2. Petstages Dogwood
- Editor rating: 9.3/10
Detailed Review
The Dogwood Stick is made from a combination of natural wood and synthetic fibers, making it long-lasting, non-toxic, and offering a one-of-a-kind feel.
The toy is a better option because it can take a beating without breaking or splintering like real wood would if it stood up to hard play or strong gnawing.
Products made from a combination of natural wood and nylon are so tough that even the most destructive chewers have trouble breaking them.
Even though the dog loves real sticks, he will chew on dogwood because of its original BBQ aroma.
Petstages products are compressed in China, yet they are still US-made products of the highest quality because the ingredients are all American-made.
This dogwood contains synthetic materials that, if ingested, could cause choking or digestive problems.
To avoid injuries, it’s important to keep an eye out for signs of wear and tear on these toys on a regular basis.
These playthings are typically built stronger and meant to withstand the chewing habits of dogs and are therefore not suitable for games of fetch, tossing, or tugging due to their weight.
| Pros | Cons |
| Alternative to real wood sticks, effectively prevent splinters | Too heavy to use for playing fetch |
| Redirect dogs’ chewing behavior and keep them away from objects |
3. Deer Shed Antlers Dog Chew– Perfect Pet Chews
- Editor rating: 9.3/10
Detailed Review
Deer Shed Antlers from Perfect Pet Chews are a premium, all-natural, organic, and long-lasting treat with smooth edges. The antlers are sourced from naturally shed antlers within the US; no harm is caused to animals during the collection process.
These antlers are the strongest chew available and do not splinter or break into dangerous pieces, making them safe for dogs.
Antlers clean teeth by scraping off plaque and contributing to strong teeth with minerals like calcium, phosphorus, and other nutrients.
I haven’t experienced any bad smells, splitting, or pieces breaking off from these antlers. I was initially concerned about sharp edges, but I am pleased that I didn’t have to trim any sharp or pointy areas, as this was already done.
For dogs that are aggressive chewers, it is important to select a size larger than their usual size. This will help prevent any potential choking hazards or the treat breaking apart too quickly.
The Small Long Treat size is specifically designed for dogs weighing 15-25 lbs, measuring 5-8″ in length, and weighing 1.5 oz or less, making it a perfect choice for smaller but powerful chewers.
Remember to monitor their size and take them away once they become smaller, because aggressive dogs might quickly destroy smaller antlers.
Overall, it is loved for its natural, chemical-free composition, benefits for dental health, and suitability for different chewer levels. I bet your dog will go crazy for it.
| Pros | Cons |
| Durable and long-lasting | The price may be considered high |
| Natural and organic | Some dogs may not be interested in the antlers |
| Smooth and safe for dogs | Requires supervision to prevent any accidents |
| Provide hours of chewing fun | May be too hard for some dogs |
| Suitable for aggressive chewers | Size discrepancies, may not be as large as expected |
4. Barida Tough Rope Toys
- Editor rating: 9.1/10
Detailed Review
The Barida dog play rope toy is an excellent tug toy and a healthy, non-toxic chew that promotes good dental hygiene in canines.
These eco-friendly toys for puppies, medium-sized dogs, and aggressive chewers are made in Turkey out of 100% natural cotton yarn. They are healthier and safer for your dog because they are made with eco-friendly materials and prevent waste threads and chemical colorants. I really appreciate this all-natural toy because it is constructed using all-cotton material, free of plastic and dye.
This toy has versatility across different sizes and ages; both big dogs and puppies can play on it. They provide a long-lasting and enjoyable toy for your pet to play with.
In my opinion, this product is best suited for one dog and one human, not for a group of dogs playing together.
The toy is durable and engaging, but it may lack longevity and resilience to aggressive chewing. It holds up well, but fraying and shredding occur after a few weeks, and may break apart if your dogs are aggressive chewers.
Although I was concerned about its longevity, I thought the rope bone was well-made and of high quality.
| Pros | Cons |
| Made with 100% natural cotton yarn | Mixed feelings on durability and lifespan |
| Safe and non-toxic | Not suitable for aggressive chewers |
| Suitable for various sizes and ages | Made in Turkey, not the USA |
| Promotes dental health through safe chewing | Short lifespan, and durability concerns. |
5. Creature 100 Organic Balls, 2-Pack
- Editor rating: 9.1/10
Detailed Review
Safe for canine playtime enjoyment, the dog ball is crafted from 100% organic New Zealand wool. Dogs can safely interact with this toy because it is made from recyclable materials and has eco-friendly details like printing with algae. I am pretty carefree about letting my pup play with this toy without worrying about what they may hit.
The eco-friendly packaging adds to its sustainability. I respect the company for emphasizing product safety and sustainability.
Both indoors and out, pet owners and their furry friends can have a good time with this ball. To some extent, it may be too big for small dog breeds, but it will suit all other sizes quite fine. The larger-than-tennis-ball size may keep dogs occupied for hours.
Among many toys, dogs frequently choose this ball as their preferred toy during playtime. This ball offers a natural sheep smell and soft texture for interactive play and fetch. Wool balls are safe for dogs to chew on because they are soft and won’t damage their teeth or gums when playing.
Chewing on this ball improves dental health by working the jaw muscles and increasing saliva production. These long-lasting balls can withstand even consistent chewers.
The fact that the balls can be cleaned with water makes them convenient to use and keep clean. I like that the toys don’t become as dirty as other kinds of toys.
Overall, it’s handmade appeal, eco-friendliness, durability, and comfort for dogs make it a hit.
| Pros | Cons |
| Made from natural and eco-friendly materials | May not be suitable for aggressive chewers |
| Safe for pets, free from harmful chemicals | Some dogs may lose interest in the toy over time |
| Durable and long-lasting | |
| Soft, engaging and enjoyable for dogs | |
| Washable and easy to clean |
6. Mirage Pet Knit Knacks Disco Duck
- Editor rating: 9.0/10
Detailed Review
The Knit Knacks Disco Duck from Mirage Pet Products is a cute plush toy that serves as both a fun and eco-friendly plaything. The squeaker in the toy attracts the dog’s attention and adds some extra fun.
The organic cotton and hand-knit pattern of the toy set it apart as a healthy and sustainable option to common dog chew toys. There won’t be any nasty chemicals or toxins thanks to the organic cotton fabric.
This toy is ideal for small dogs because of its manageable size and special design. The Disco Duck is not made to be chewed, but small dogs can enjoy it because its plush material is easy on their teeth and gums.
In addition, I think the price is fair for the quality and pleasure that you get out of the Mirage Pet Products Disco Duck.
Overall, the Mirage Pet Cotton Dog Toy is a natural, eco-friendly, and soft toy that won’t harm your dog’s ingestive system if he swallows it.
The Knit Knacks Disco Duck from Mirage Pet Products is a cute plush toy that serves as both a fun and eco-friendly plaything. The squeaker in the toy attracts the dog’s attention and adds some extra fun.
The organic cotton and hand-knit pattern of the toy set it apart as a healthy and sustainable option to common dog chew toys. There won’t be any nasty chemicals or toxins thanks to the organic cotton fabric.
This toy is ideal for small dogs because of its manageable size and special design. The Disco Duck is not made to be chewed, but small dogs can enjoy it because its plush material is easy on their teeth and gums.
In addition, I think the price is fair for the quality and pleasure that you get out of the Mirage Pet Products Disco Duck.
Overall, the Mirage Pet Cotton Dog Toy is a natural, eco-friendly, and soft toy that won’t harm your dog’s ingestive system if he swallows it.
| Pros | Cons |
| Squeaky design adds entertainment value | Not specifically designed as a chew toy |
| Handknit with organic cotton, eco-friendly | Limited durability for heavy chewers |
| Soft and gentle on teeth and gums | |
| Offers a natural and safe play experience | |
| Reasonably priced |
7. West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Dog Bone Chew Toy
- Editor rating: 8.9/10
Detailed Review
The West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Dog Bone Chew Toy is a tough, bouncy, floatable bone chew toy that is ideal for dogs that are rough on toys. You can play it with your dog both in the water or on dry land, and it’s much less dangerous than using real wood sticks. The toy is free of any harmful materials and may be recycled after use. The toy comes with manufacturer’s 100% guarantee against damage, and can be cleaned in the dishwasher.
Sizes range from small (appropriate for a 14-pound puppy) to large (ideal for a golden retriever puppy of 3-6 months old), making this toy suited for a wide variety of dog breeds and owners’ tastes. My two dogs have very powerful chewing habits, yet the toy has held up nicely over the years.
Because of his design, Hurley is portable and easy to hide away. The narrow middle of the toy makes it easier for dogs to seal their lips around it, reducing the likelihood that they may drink too much water. Because of this quality, it is ideal for use in water settings like swimming pools and lakes.
I also like that I can save time and effort washing the toy because it can go in the dishwasher.
However, some dogs may find the toy too intense to chew on, and it takes some time to get the item frozen solid. The heavy weight of the toy also makes it difficult to throw.
Overall, West Paw’s product is one I wholeheartedly endorse. It floats, can withstand even the most violent chewers, and can be cleaned with minimal effort.
| Pros | Cons |
| Durable and long-lasting | Heavier weight, not suitable for small or toy breeds |
| Designed for aggressive chewers | Some color options may fade over time |
| Floatable for water play | Some dogs may lose interest in it quickly |
| Reduces water intake during retrieval | |
| Easy to clean (dishwasher safe) |
8. Mutty Dog Chew Ring, Non Toxic
- Rating: 9.0/10
Detailed Review
The Mutty Dog Chew Ring is fantastic for calming antsy or bored dogs or stopping harmful dog habits. Mutty toys are sturdy yet flexible, with chew rings made from super-durable food-grade materials. It’s made of 100% food-grade rubber and puts animal safety first.
The chew rings are resilient and stretchy, so they won’t break under your energetic dog’s teeth. Mutty places a high priority on product safety. They undergo rigorous testing, similar to those used for baby teethers, to ensure high safety standards.
Other so-called “indestructible” toys have a reputation for smelling like car tires, but this one does not have that flaw. Mutty’s superior quality and safety can also be traced to its manufacturing in the United States rather than a less expensive country.
Mutty donates one meal to a local shelter for every toy purchased, showcasing their commitment to animal and social welfare.
However, dogs may have lost interest in the ring toy because of its smooth texture; dogs have strong preferences for particular textures like a little rug or bumpy surface, and a smooth surface may not give as much tactile stimulation.
Overall, Mutty is a reliable and responsible brand for pet owners, offering safe, modern, chew-friendly, and durable toys.
| Pros | Cons |
| Made with food-grade rubber, ensuring safety | Not chew-proof for big dogs and heavy chewers |
| Sturdy and durable | Lack of interest from some dogs, potentially due to texture |
| Flexible design prevents tooth damage | Relatively thick ring may not be ideal for tug-o-war play |
| Supports local animal shelters through meal donations | |
| Neutral colors and modern design |
